Tuesday, June 10, 2008

All about the new comments...

The Problem:

So, in case you hadn't noticed there has been a little bit of an issue with the comments since Easterns and Westerns. As a result we had to scale back and only allow registered users, this helped in some ways - there were fewer people posting inane or offensive content. However they still posted with some surprising regularity.

The Solution:

An entirely new commenting system. We have moved away from the Blogger default comment system and installed a system called Intense Debate. It will allow for anonymous comments, BUT it will allow for greater moderation as well - including IP banning, user blocking, etc.

What does that mean?:

It means that PlayUltimate now has a more fully functional commenting system with the following awesome capabilities...

  • Nested comments - reply exactly to the message you want to inline, your comment doesnt automatically filter to the bottom of the page
  • Comment organization - you can click to reorganize comments by Date, Rating or Last Activity
  • You can now RATE EVERY COMMENT, give them a thumbs up or thumbs down, your votes will determine that posters credibility. The top 10 commenters will be displayed on the right hand side.
  • You can post anonymously, but its discouraged - you wont be able to make the commenting leader board, people wont be able to connect you between comments. Also when you log in you can choose to be notified of follow up comments via email. And a slew of other cool features. If you are anonymous you also can not vote on other posts.
  • Logging in - IntenseDebate uses the OpenID platform, so if you have a login for Blogger, Livejournal, AOL, SmugMug, Flickr Yahoo or a ton of other sites - you already have a login, no need to create a new account.
  • When you log in - you will get the option to create a profile so other people on the site can know a little bit about you - who you play for etc. This is entirely optional though of course.
  • RSS Feeds - is there a comment thread that particularly interests you? you subscribe to the RSS feed for any comment section on the site.
There are a ton more cool features but those are the basics.

If you didn't feel like reading that, just poke around, know that everyone can comment now, but the community will help moderate. If someone is perennially being voted down and saying offensive things, we will block them. No questions asked.

Let the debate begin...

Over the next few weeks I'll post a few more times regarding new features on the site, feel free to poke around in the meantime though.

Comments (5)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
anonymous's avatar

anonymous · 878 weeks ago

McCabe, great job with the commenting. It seems to be a good solution. So now how about we try it out a little? Anybody have any predictions for YCC's? They're only two months away. I think the pennsbury columbia combo from the Delaware Valley League, Seattle, New England, and Pittsburgh will be the top four teams. However, Minnesota with players from five different teams that went to westerns (south, eden prarie, hopkins, cretin derham, and cathedral) could definitely sneak their way into the semis. Anyone know how much worlds is affecting these teams? New England will be without Jonah herscu (amherst), tommy li (longmeadow), and andrew kieffer (amherst), but they will have jonah's brother misha (amherst), julian summa (amherst), worlds alternate ryan rzepka (longmeadow), and spencer diamond (amherst). Seattle will be missing Julian C-W (lakeside) and michael revelaas (SAAS). Anyone know if they will be missing matt rehder? Is he playing at worlds with sockeye? Does anyone know if any college players from seattle's team last year (Sam K-S, Ben vigus, etc.) are eligible to play?

Just hoping to get something started here...
Yeah, worlds will certainly make this a less exciting year for YCC. Losst of Julian C-W, Revelas, and maybe even Rehder will hurt seattle also the loss of various other NWschool students if they'e not eligible.

What teams got in on phase 2 applications?
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
anonymous 's avatar

anonymous · 878 weeks ago

can we open up new easterns/westerns threads....seeing as no one really got to say anything about them and the upa write ups are just the worst
will do, i'm going to put one up shortly

lots and lots of posts today.

i think i'll put a new one up for YCCs tomorrow?
agreed

Post a new comment

Comments by