Here is an interesting question for people interested in West Coast HS ultimate. Should boys ultimate move to the fall?
It is my educated guess that boys ultimate will be in the fall in Seattle starting in fall of 2008.
The problem in Washington is that boys soccer, boys lacrosse, boys track, boys baseball, and for some schools boys tennis are all in the spring. The two main sports in the fall are cross country and football. To top all that off less than half the schools that play ultimate play boys because coed HS ultimate has been around for 10+ years.
The final nail in the coffin for boys ultimate in the spring of 06 came when the state association recently moved class 1A (small but not smallest classification) soccer to the spring. That means that two of the big four ultimate schools, Northwest and Seattle Academy, which are both 1A schools will very likely have soccer in the spring starting in 09. Both those schools are most likely too small to still be able to field ultimate teams. The two bigger schools, Nathan Hale and Lakeside, already play spring soccer.
But clearly this is about more than two small schools. This is about how best to get the sport to grow much much bigger. Here are the upsides:
- For the bigger schools including Seattle public, there would only really be competition with football and cross country.
- There is already a coed MS Seattle Public Schools sponsored league. An open Seattle Public HS league could maybe use those fields right after the MS in exchange for HS players helping coach the MS players. The HS kids would get free game fields and volunteer hours needed for graduation. There could be cross over games versus private and non-Seattle public schools on park fields during the week.
- It is difficult to find HS coaches in spring. UW and other college ultimate players in the area would most likely be able to coach much more in the fall as long as sectionals and regionals don't conflict for adult club.
- There would be more coaches available in the spring because many boys coaches could also coach girls and vice versa.
- The independent schools in the Emerald City 1A league with Northwest and Seattle Academy would be much more likely to make boys ultimate in the fall a varsity sport since they would only have cross country and are not likely to add football.
- BC is rumored to want to add boys ultimate. They have a well organized spring coed league. This would not conflict.
- If boys want to play coed in the spring and there are significantly more boys playing ultimate then there would have to be significantly more girls playing. As soon as a school has enough girls for two coed teams they have enough for a girls team. Girls games could happen on diferent days than coed leagues.
- Boys State would be in the fall.
Here are the big questions:
- Would BC, Oregon, and California have boys ultimate in the fall?
- Would Colorado add a boys in the fall?
- Would the UPA move Westerns to the fall for boys? Could we get fields in California for Westerns?
- What would happen with the Minnesota schools? They are a great part of westerns?
What do people think? Is this the way to best grow the sport?
-Mike
